SB Nation - Login for mobile commenting

The Phinsider

Wednesday Night Random Thread:Best Case Scenario At QB Edition

GREEN BAY, WI - DECEMBER 11: Aaron Rodgers #12 of the Green Bay Packers throws a pass against the Oakland Raiders at Lambeau Field on December 11, 2011 in Green Bay, Wisconsin. (Photo by Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images)

Jonathan Daniel - Getty Images

5 months ago: GREEN BAY, WI - DECEMBER 11: Aaron Rodgers #12 of the Green Bay Packers throws a pass against the Oakland Raiders at Lambeau Field on December 11, 2011 in Green Bay, Wisconsin. (Photo by Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images)

For the most part the one thing that is we can all come to agreement on here at the Phinsider is that we need improved play and numbers from the starting QB position. Be it improvement of one of our current players or from a drafted new guy or even the free agent signing of a big name QB that we all assume will come free very soon. this of course leads me to our question of the night and........wait for it..........even a poll. I know, your excited!

Star-divide


So my question is if you could have literally any QB you wanted starting for the Dolphins next season who would it be? It does not have to be someone that is available, just someone that is still playing or will be playing in the NFL next season.

Poll
Who would you start at QB if you could choose anyone?
Matt Moore
20 votes
Chad Henne
9 votes
J.P. Losman
3 votes
Pat Devlin
8 votes
Peyton Manning
68 votes
Aaron Rodgers
312 votes
Ben Roethlisberger
3 votes
Drew Brees
121 votes
Tom Brady
50 votes
Eli Manning
26 votes
Cam Newton
43 votes
Matt Ryan
6 votes
Andy Dalton
3 votes
Tim Tebow
8 votes
Matt Flynn
46 votes
Philip Rivers
5 votes
Andrew Luck
71 votes
Robert Griffin III
62 votes
Brandon Weeden
3 votes
Brock Osweiler
3 votes
Kirk Cousins
2 votes
Nick Foles
1 votes
Ryan Lindley
2 votes
Someone not listed (please note below)
9 votes

884 votes | Poll has closed

0 recs  |  191 comments

Comments

Either Aaron or Cam

That would be awesome. Probably Aaron though because of his relationship with Philbin.

whoever voted brady on this site should go jump off a bridge

I am very much for opposing opinions too. just not that one.

LOL Take it easy there tiger.
Hey pipedreaming again!
I voted for Cam

But I can understand the Brady pick. Kills 2 birds with 1 stone.

lol

wow Brady got 9 votes… Gisselle must have been praying vervantly LOL

I picked Cam
Also, I like Brock "the rock" Osweiler

After a few years on the bench

Hey everyone, I had to redo the poll as it did not post properly. Sorry for the confusion.
It will turn into a CKC at 10:30 then!
I like me some Brock-weiler, too

But if we have Flynn, I see him having long-term potential.

I picked Cam .....again.
Ok the poll is still screwed. Somehow we are missing a major QB there
hmmmm......Aaron Rodgers is only 28.

Did he already retire? lol.

No. In case you have not noticed we are having some site issues today. I had to repost the poll 3 times.
Refresh your page!!!!!!
I was just joking around.

I understand that the site has had some problems.

It was hell trying to get that post right for some reason.
OK! Now its fixed.
I picked Cam once again
I would like to formally thank you for your courage that you have shown today by multi-voting!
So ... If you're picking for the Dolphins at No.8/9, who are you taking?
Who me?
Anyone, I guess
You know mine.
Draft Riley Reiff with the 8/9 spot to protect Peyton Manning.

Then draft either Tannehill in the second round or Osweiler in the third round to learn behind Manning. If we go with Osweiler in the third (which I am leaning towards since he has the strongest arm in the draft, but is very raw so could use a few years behind Manning) then sign a sick TE in the second. Fleener if he’s available when we pick. Sign Robert Mathis as our pass rusher.

Reply fail....

_

We have all been there.
Trade down for Dwayne Allen

2nd round: Melvin Ingrim or Nick Perry
3rd round: Brock Osweiler

There is no way that Ingram makes it out of the first round.

I doubt he’ll even be available outside of the top 15 picks. It’s been reported we have Robert Mathis in our sights in FA. That would be a better idea.

I love Mathis (a proud member of Ball so hard university)

But he is a bit old

I voted Eli

His sideline pass in the Super Bowl was epic….

Eli is underrated IMO and I thought that before the Superbowl.
i voted Eli too before I read this...
By the way for all of those of you that are having issues accessing the fan posts you can do so via the button

at the top of the page. They WILL be back up on the front page on the right side once the widget is fixed.

DUKE/NORTH CAROLINA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
You mean they are playing or are you pointing out that Duke lived in North Carolina?
lol

They are playing.

Random Trivia question of the night:

What Ring of Honor member had the shortest career with the Dolphins?

(And I'm not counting the 1972 team)
Warfield?
He was only there for a few. He was like a loaner.
Ding ding ding ding

1970-1974

I know me some Dolphins stuff.
Okay....

Who stole Snowflake?

Finkle/Eihorn
rofl
She was better looking in Stripes.
candy stripes or the one with Bill Murrey!
The one with Bill.
True
She was also good in Ghostbusters

I’m interested in her because she sleeps above her covers, 5 feet above her covers. Best Bill Murrey line ever

Sean Young was not in Ghostbusters.
He hehehehehehehehehehehehehehe!
Yes she was she was the female lead
My mistake Sigourney Weaver
LOL
At least she keep her sheets on in that one!
uhhhhh sigourney weaver!
beat me too it lol
I checked on my DVD after I posted it
I had to look up how to spell her 1st name , lol

who the hell names their kid sigourney ?

People who suck

They just suck

Morral?

I assume he is in the R.O.H and he was old when he came here

3 years ago Manning would be a no brainer

but Rodgers today.

What's up

And there at three scenarios I like:
1. Take Peyton and draft osweiler in te 3rd
2. Take Flynn and draft Dominique Davis in the 6th
3. Take peyton and draft Jordan Rodgers next year

I didn’t list RGIII because I doubt we will be able to get him.

Can't see the poll

But I want Cam Newton

Get ready for negativity, everyone!

J/k, bud.

Lol my job

Is to poop on parades

Yes it is Debbie.
Sounds like an important job ...

FOR ME TO POOP ON!

Lol
Im pretty sure the saying is to rai on parades
Thats not as funny
Truth
How do you poop ON anything

I coould understand if you said your job is to poop UNDER parades

Ladders

Stools (pun intended), balconies, etc etc

helium balloons , do a float over !
I am accepting of Trolls and such voting for Brady, Moore or Henne...BUT NOT TEBOW

He has the Football IQ of a HS Freshman Cheerleader and the throwing arm of one too.

Oh my! Prepare for an onslaught.
A god loving Hs cheerleader
That is an Urban Myth...God loving HS Cheerleaders don't exist...not even in Christian Schools.
I read that wrong the first time

I read that is an Urban Meyer

Yes, Urban Meyer is a godloving HS Cheerleader
Henne

I’m one of the only people left on this planet that still thinks the Dolphins can be succesful with Henne.

Probably.
No, definately...
Hmmm
I'm pretty sure drumzan is correct , he is the only one who believes it !
Henne is the anti-Eli. He can put up as many numbers as you want (not really but for sake of argument) but in the 4th Quarter when it counts. When you have to have that game winning drive, Chad Henne has and will always fold.

How many 4th quarter interceptions can one guy have?

apparently , one too many !
Hey Tona!
wut's up beav
came looking for a CKC!
3 minutes till 10:30

but I cant see fanposts on my side bar, is it just me?

Tunes are the spice of life!
29 career passing TD's to 36 int's
54 attempts 22 attempts for a 40.74% completion ratio career in the 4th Q
Well...

He never had a running game last year or in his 4 games this year. Probably could’ve beaten the Pats if the defence wasn’t so terrible that game. Give him a right side of the o-line and I think he’ll be a different player. He showed too much improvement this year to give up on him. He really had a tough job adding 5 new pieces to the offence and a new o-coordinator in very little time.

Just took another breath Lmao even harder. Tell me if you know this one, Willy, Kris, Waylon, Johny?.
I do. Have a Highwaymen album on vinyl.
Kiss my flat bottum tail awsum!
Yeah I have quite a collection of music.
it the second stanza Iwas a damn builder across the river deep & wide where the steele & water did colide!
steel? I thought you were a beaver not a welder , lol

that steel will be a little rough on your chompers !

I'm strong man iner strenth!
lol, and a strong beaver needs his iron !
I'm real sure you here Waylon sing my faveriot part!
What part?
Opps it's the second stanza; Iwas a damn builder across the river deep & wide where the steele & water did colide!
HigkwayMan
Bacus?
Kinda a lyric theif irls wanna have fun but ok!
How sad is it that I'm watching real world road rules challenge
truly sad my friend !
Life will kill you dont listen to them!
Pretty damn sad.
I turned off South Park for it

What the heck is wrong with me

I would say sunstroke ....... but it's nightime !
Not sure. I am still on SP.
No not remorse show sum spunk, Giel, retallyation coud be a wrong move also
Half way into his career Cash flip into a gospel singer i belived it save his career todoly!
Crist you even got sum snow this year!
Who?
NW Texas no!
Oh yeah. They have had like 4 full on blizzards out that way this year.

My sister in laws folks live out that way.

It can get bad with the people not understanding whats going on!
I'm waiting for the snow down here.

It usually hits in March-April for some reason.

They know up there.
Almost got a job up North working at a nuklear power plant!
That's just what we need...

… a stoned dude working nuclear.

It will be ok, I think.......
Beav in a nuclear power plant

May be the scariest thing I have EVER heard.

Acertain car accident got in the way!
Yeah that sucks. Glad your still with us Beav.
4 Votes for Chad Henne?

Seriously? and no votes for Dan Marino to come back?

It does not have to be someone that is available, just someone that is still playing or will be playing in the NFL next season.
No kidding...

Even if the question was who “realistically” you wanted, that’s crazy.

But over Aaron Rodgers or anyone else? That’s just… well, I shouldn’t use any of the words that describe how ________ that is.

Way to miss the point.
So help me out...

What point am I missing?

Were the four people who voted for Henne were trying to be ironic?

Iconic is the answer & yes this is for fun cuz u cee no mater what we say, we have no say in the mater!
I thought you were questioning the poll itself.
Ah. Cool.

No, not questioning the poll at all, just the four, wait, now NINE, people who would choose Henne over anyone else in the NFL. That’s just __________.

one question

Why is j.p losman an option?

Because he is still on our roster.
He is?

I thought we released his sorry excuse of an arm

He was injured right? I am sure he will be gone in the off season.

just so ya know tex i am NEVER excited for a poll but i am ALWAYS exicted for a hole ;op

It's all in the spelling sir.
How about Devlin?

I know a lot of you are likely NFL bigots that don’t watch a ton of college ball, so I’d like to point out that Pat Devlin should at least get a serious evaluation by the new coaching staff. He broke some passing records in PA, set by QBs such as Marino, Montana, and Namath to name just a few. In the minds of many, he should have been a two-year starter at Penn State, but ended up transferring to Delaware (does the name Flacco ring a bell?) where he had two solid years and took the Blue Hens to a championship game. I think before the Dolphins go spend a fortune (in dollars or draft picks) on someone else with no guarantee of success, that they should at least give him a good look.

Well hot damn Tex wood i be "a Bigot" if you know what bigots are. Your not a bigot, Mosul no bigot

Wait (Alpha’s Monkey) might be a biggot, haven’t stoped to look but there are a few that watch sum “College” more now then of past years cuz of said lock-out last year!

Don't you think they are?
So your making an assumption that they are not?
Lol
Best case scenario: Back to the Future part 4...

You carjack doc’s time machine, travel back to the 80’s and convince Dan Marino in his prime to return with you to save a Miami Dolphins franchise that has been horrid at quarterback since he retired.

Ricky Williams!



no wait

What was the question?

where is the sanchize!!! he is missing off the list

Is he still playing? Oh my bad.........
How is Tom Brandstater not listed?!
We don't vote on gods.
Of course, i will seek forgiveness

You must Login with your SB Nation account and be a member of The Phinsider to post a comment.