Over the last few days, the rumors of former Kansas City Chiefs President Carl Peterson joining the Miami Dolphins as their next football czar. Then again, the reports come out right after those rumors that Peterson won't be hired by the Dolphins. Either way, right now, Peterson is an "advisor" to Dolphins owner Stephen Ross and general manager Jeff Ireland.
But, if Peterson is going to be directly involved in the Dolphins search for a new head coach, whether he eventually becomes an official part of the franchise or not, we as fans need to know exactly who Peterson is. With Peterson having been with the Kansas City Chiefs from 1989 until 2008 , what better way to learn about Peterson than from our SB Nation sister blog, the outstanding Arrowhead Pride.

I asked Joel Thorman for his impression of what the Dolphins would be getting with Peterson, He replied:
"Carl Peterson was extremely successful with the Kansas City Chiefs in the 1990s, and sporadically in the 2000s. The Chiefs were among the winningest teams that decade, they always had a supreme defense and they made the playoffs almost every year. They were, in many respects, a model franchise in that decade. Things fell off a bit in the 2000s but overall the Chiefs were generally a good (but not Super Bowl caliber) team in Peterson's tenure.
"Peterson was good at a lot of things, the Chiefs had some great players that he drafted -- lookin' at you, Derrick Thomas -- and you have to give him credit for that. But you also have to recognize two big blemishes on his record -- 1.) The Chiefs never drafted and developed a franchise quarterback, or even a decent backup, in Peterson's time. 2.) The Chiefs never made it to the Super Bowl in his time (and, in fact, they didn't win a playoff game from January 1994 to Peterson's exit in December 2008). Those are two big misses in nearly two decades at the helm.
"So Peterson's a bit of a mixed bag. Yes, he built great Chiefs teams with lots of good players that he drafted but he was never able to build a complete team (i.e. one with a quarterback). He always took the veteran route when it came to acquiring quarterbacks -- three straight backup 49ers QBs in Joe Montana, Steve Bono and Elvis Grbac -- and I think the ability to draft a quarterback is a requirement at this point. Peterson never showed he could do that."
Like Joel said, drafting a quarterback is probably a requirement in Miami right now. And, if Peterson can't do that, that's not a promising situation - especially if the rumors of Peterson being hired and forcing Ireland out and taking the player decisions for himself, or for one of his former staff from his days with the Chiefs, are true.
I would like to thank Joel for taking the time to give us a little but about Peterson. Now we all have to sit back and wait to see what role Peterson truly has - or winds up getting - with the Dolphins, and how much sway he has over his friend and business partner Ross.
0 recs | 19 comments
i have alot of family and friends who are chiefs fans
and none have anything good to say about Carl…
BSerious72 - January 5, 2012
I can see Ross hiring Marty Shottenheimer to right the ship
he has never finished less than 8-8 and always makes the playoffs.
Jcrew1179 - January 6, 2012
change hos to his ;)
dolfinfan34 - January 5, 2012 via mobile
no thanks...keep the hos, get rid of all the hises
Phinphinatic - January 5, 2012
F**k that! Talk about aspiring to mediocrity!
Hire a guy that has never done anything significant or been a part of a winning gig. Hell no! This isn’t some green coordinator, this guys has been in two decades. Please no!
Youngstown_Phinatic - January 5, 2012
i'm telling you all... lets get that sparano guy
he is hungry for another shot!
Phinphinatic - January 5, 2012
:D
joel311 - January 6, 2012
Maybe he will break out in his second chance like Billacheat did.
texascowpunk - January 6, 2012
I really hope so, but doubt it.
I wish him the best.
Phinphinatic - January 6, 2012
Same. I always want to see the good guys do well.
texascowpunk - January 6, 2012
I think it's time to put my head in the sand.
Tunaflipper - January 5, 2012
No time for that, Tuna.
We learned 2 things from Joel and hopefully Peterson did to. Franchise qb is a must, not going to say retreads don’t work, for Brees has bucked that notion. Secondly, we need to find a new GM because Ireland is following in his footsteps.
fin4three5yrs - January 6, 2012
Ireland has had ONE DRAFT.
joel311 - January 6, 2012
This^
texascowpunk - January 6, 2012
Although I should've mentioned
That Carl was also largely responsible for helping turn Arrowhead into one of the best game day experiences in the NFL. That was a big focus of his, turning it into an event. And it’s hard to argue he failed there (although, even after he’s gone, I’m still going to complain about 30 bucks to park the car).
Joel Thorman - January 6, 2012
I wonder if thats where the orange carpet type ideas came from
Ross has been trying to elevate the “fan experience” at the stadium on game days since he took over. I, being one that attends the games, appreciate the attempt to increase my experience but find my experience is elevated much more via victorys. After that I’m all for orange carpets and celebrity owners and night clubs.
My best game day experience is one where the opposing fans aren’t cheering on the way out of the stadium….
-Thanks for some insight into Peterson. He’s like a lurking shadow to us over here.
FinsSince70 - January 6, 2012
I have no problem with Peterson being an 'advisor', lord knows Ross needs one he can trust.
The problem I have is the perception. When your ‘advisor’ is on a helicopter ride attempting to woo a coach, that’s going over and above what an ‘advisor’ should be imo.
I’m sure plenty of owners have advisors, but they aren’t in the public eye and sending mixed signals as to what their roles are.
FinFinatic - January 6, 2012
3 QBs from SF...
Sounds like he has a condition similar to Parcell’s Dallas disease…
Wori - January 6, 2012
Just say no to King Carl
Patssuck456 - January 7, 2012
You must Login with your SB Nation account and be a member of The Phinsider to post a comment.