SB Nation - Login for mobile commenting

The Phinsider

kmb8488's 2012 NFL Mock Draft - 4.0

Welcome back. It's been so long since we last talked.

Now that the Jan. 15 deadline to declare has passed, we officially know which college prospects will be available in the 2012 NFL Draft. Unfortunately for quarterback-hungry Dolphins fans, it looks like the asking price for the right to draft Robert Griffin III will be flat-out insane. This means Miami could take a best-player-available strategy (a great thing, in my opinion) into the draft this April.

This week, I have the Dolphins selecting a less-than-glamorous prospect who just happens to be a mammoth talent--able to come in and contribute from day one. I am just telling you this now in case you were expecting to see Griffin or Andrew Luck as the Dolphins' selection. I am not that cruel.

Anyway, enough chatter. Let's take a look at how the first round of the 2012 NFL Draft would play out if held today.

Star-divide

1) Indianapolis Colts - Andrew Luck, QB Stanford

Not much needs to be said to validate the selection of Andrew Luck at this spot. He's everything teams look for in a quarterback--the mind and arm of a classic pocket passer, coupled with durability and above-average athleticism for the position. In fact, Luck's such a special prospect, his pending arrival in Indianapolis has already led to the firings of Colts Vice Chairman Bill Polian, General Manager Chris Polian and head coach Jim Caldwell. That's impressive stuff.

2) St. Louis Rams - Justin Blackmon, WR Oklahoma State

Jason Smith's likely departure suggests the Rams will use this selection to add a premier left tackle, but quarterback Sam Bradford needs weapons in the worst possible way, and Oklahoma State wide receiver Justin Blackmon has been on St. Louis' radar since January 2011 (when he was the second- or third-best receiver behind A.J. Green). Easily the No.1 wideout in a strong 2012 receiver class, Blackmon will bring a physical go-to presence to a Rams receiver corps that couldn't get any worse at this point, and he might be able to give St. Louis' backfield some breathing room, as well.

3) Minnesota Vikings - Matt Kalil, OT USC

Despite an ultra-meaningless win in Washington on Christmas Eve, the Vikings could still end up with the 2012 draft prospect they need the most: USC's Matt Kalil. Minnesota's offensive line desperately needs a franchise-caliber presence on the left side, and Kalil is a herculean-type prospect who combines phenomenal upper body strength with impressive technique and footwork. Consider this: The Vikings' offensive line is the worst in the NFC North. It almost takes effort to be that bad.

4) Cleveland Browns - Robert Griffin III, QB Baylor

The Browns claim they're good with quarterback Colt McCoy? That means Baylor's Robert Griffin III should probably brace himself for a move to Cleveland. Unfortunately for the Heisman Trophy winner, the Browns are short on talent in the receiver corps and backfield, so it's going to be an uphill climb the moment Griffin joins the Dawg Pound. Still, RG3 is an unbelievably gifted--both physically and mentally--quarterback prospect who could have the Browns' offense clicking sooner rather than later.

5) Tampa Bay Buccaneers - Morris Claiborne, CB LSU

For a defense that was supposedly a linebacker and cornerback away from becoming a premier unit, the Buccaneers took a colossal step backward in 2011. Tampa has needed a premier cornerback for a while now, and LSU's Morris Claiborne is about as premier as it gets at that position. Claiborne isn't a physical freak, but his man-coverage skills are near unparalleled, which would buy the Buccaneers' burgeoning defensive line a bit more time to get to the quarterback.

6) Washington Redskins - Jonathan Martin, OT Stanford

With Robert Griffin III off the board, the Redskins will likely turn to its next-biggest need and select the best offensive tackle available. Now, I don't believe Stanford's Jonathan Martin is actually the best tackle available at this juncture, but his outrageously solid ability as a run blocker will suit him to the right side of the Washington's hologram-like offensive line. Great need meets greater value in this scenario.

7) Jacksonville Jaguars - Dre Kirkpatrick, CB Alabama

Dre Kirkpatrick looked like a fast, heavy-hitting stork during the BCS National Championship Game, but the big story about the Alabama cornerback this season was his huge improvement in coverage. Kirkpatrick still lacks top instincts at the corner position, but he's ultra-physical when playing the run and has the speed and length to disrupt in coverage.

8) Miami Dolphins - Riley Reiff, OT Iowa

The selection of another offensive lineman in the first round might send Dolphins fans into a Jonestown-like frenzy, but with quarterback options likely available via free agency (Matt Flynn, unless the Packers pull some funny stuff) or in the second round of the 2012 draft (Arizona's Nick Foles, Texas A&M's Ryan Tannehill), the Dolphins should look to match need with value at this spot. Iowa offensive tackle Riley Reiff has the potential to be the best offensive tackle in this class, and would lock up the right side of a Dolphins offensive line that was absolutely violated throughout season. Also, don't forget that potential Dolphins head coach Joe Philbin did his best work in Green Bay with an Iowa Hawkeye (Bryan Bulaga) at right tackle.

9) Carolina Panthers - Michael Brockers, DT LSU

Regardless of Carolina's defensive scheme next season, it's entirely possible Panthers head coach Ron Rivera will develop a serious man-crush on LSU behemoth defensive tackle Michael Brockers. A disruptive force in the trenches this season--and one of the lone bright spots for LSU in the BCS National Championship Game--Brockers excels at collapsing the pocket, and he'll become even more devastating once he refines his hand technique at the line of scrimmage.

10) Buffalo Bills - Whitney Mercilus, DE/OLB Illinois

The Bills need a gung-ho pass rusher, and could have a tough time selecting between Illinois' Whitney Mercilus and Alabama's Courtney Upshaw. The clincher for Mercilus could be his insanely close resemblance to San Francisco pass-rushing monster Aldon Smith (they also both wore the same college number: 85). Mercilus is an edge rusher with great speed, length and power, and he'd do great damage in a defense that already features Marcell Dareus and Kyle Williams.

11) Kansas City Chiefs - Trent Richardson, RB Alabama

Chiefs running back Jamal Charles proved this season that he's a little on the frail side, and with questions remaining at the quarterback position, the Chiefs simply cannot undergo another year with an injury-plagued backfield. Alabama's Trent Richardson is far and away the best running back prospect in this draft class, equipped with the speed and thick build to tear off big plays and withstand the pounding that AFC West defenses can dole out. And he'd be an absolutely steal at this spot, as well.

12) Seattle Seahawks - Quinton Coples, DE North Carolina

Thanks to the emergence of their secondary, Seattle can address its godawful pass rush with a franchise-caliber defensive end at this spot. North Carolina's Quinton Coples is equally capable of smashing quarterbacks or destroying the run, and that's why he should maybe think about buying some flannel shirts this spring.

13) Arizona Cardinals - David DeCastro, G Stanford

Yes, this is a very high spot to take a guard, but when that guard is arguably one of the best to ever play college football, it's probably okay to reach a bit. And when your interior offensive line is as godawful as Arizona's, then reaching on a freakish guard like David DeCastro is pretty much a no-brainer. For those of you who went through the 2011 season wondering how Beanie Wells was racking up huge yardage behind the Cardinals' porous offensive line, imagine how he'll do with DeCastro bulldozing paths well into the second level of defense.

14) Dallas Cowboys - Janoris Jenkins, CB North Alabama

Cornerback is a flat-out necessity for the Cowboys, who were helplessly slapped around by the Giants receivers in Week 17 Janoris Jenkins, despite the fact he couldn't behave himself while at Gainesville for three seasons, is a corner prospect with excellent technique and the ability to play much bigger than his listed size (5'10", 180). Check out his near-domination of A.J. Green during the Florida/Georgia game in 2010 if you need further evidence that Jenkins is the real deal.

15) Philadelphia Eagles - Luke Kuechly, ILB Boston College

Philadelphia's linebacker corps is as bad as it gets--in need of athleticism, awareness and plain old hitting ability. Boston College's Luke Kuechly isn't the fastest linebacker prospect in this draft class, but he's absolutely the smartest and most technically sound. You could even make the case that Kuechly's ability to diagnose and attack the play borders on genius level.

Keuchly (6'2", 235) will remind you of a taller, faster Zach Thomas.

16) New York Jets - Courtney Upshaw, OLB Alabama

The Jets' pass rush has looked deplorable this season, and since Gang Green is now struggling to control the trenches (losing Shaun Ellis and Kris Jenkins probably didn't help in this regard), the least New York can do is add a legitimate edge rusher and put some heat on opposing on quarterbacks.

Alabama's Courtney Upshaw looks every bit the part of a game-changing pass rusher, combining a stout (6'2, 270) frame with good athleticism, heavy hands and the ability to take on and dominate blocks. Upshaw is also capable of either dropping into coverage or busting up the run, and has the instincts and overall intelligence to be a cerebral defender at the next level. He's the total package as a 3-4 outside linebacker.

17) Cincinnati Bengals - Alfonzo Dennard, CB Nebraska

You're just asking for it when Nate Clements and Kelly Jennings are holding it down for you at corner. And though the Bengals will have Leon Hall back next year, Cincinnati needs to find a young, shutdown corner who can come up and smack the run. Nebraska's Alfonzo Dennard is an undersized corner prospect with loads of athleticism, and he has the stout build and great leaping ability to take on bigger, stronger receivers. Dennard isn't as big or technically refined as former Cornhusker (and current New York Giants stud) corner Prince Amukamara, but he might actually have better ball skills at this point.

18) San Diego Chargers - Nick Perry, DE/OLB USC

Lack of quarterback pressure on defense was a big reason for San Diego's sub-par 2011 season, and it's not going to get any better until the Bolts commit to improving their pass rush from the edge. The Chargers won't have to travel far to get a glimpse of what USC outside linebacker Nick Perry is capable of on the football field, as he absolutely tore it up for the Trojans in 2011. Perry is a defensive end who has the speed and active hands to seamlessly transition to outside linebacker in the 3-4, which makes him an ideal prospect for a Chargers defense that needs sacks pronto.

19) Chicago Bears - Peter Konz, C Wisconsin

It's hard to believe that, on a Chicago Bears offensive line bereft of talent, center is actually the team's biggest need. Wisconsin's Peter Konz is a mammoth-yet-cerebral center prospect who has all the traits often found in Wisconsin offensive linemen--size, strength, intelligence and a surprising level of athleticism. Despite suffering a dislocated ankle this season, Konz proved week in and week out that he was the best center in college football, and he'll probably quickly assert himself in the trenches at the next level.

20) Tennessee Titans - Mark Barron, S Alabama

Do-everything safeties will be in short supply this spring, which should add to Alabama safety Mark Barron's already impressive draft stock. Barron is athletic enough to play centerfield in passing downs and physical enough to come up and take on the run. And though he lacks elite speed for the position, he's as complete a safety prospect as you'll find in this draft.

21) Cincinnati Bengals - Lamar Miller, RB Miami

Cedric Benson's on the back end of his stay in Cincinnati, and the Bengals really need a powerful, explosive running back to complement their burgeoning pass attack. Lamar Miller has the game-changing speed and prototypical build to make a difference against the stout defenses in the AFC North, so he could be an ideal selection for the Bengals at this spot.

22) Cleveland Browns (via Atlanta) - Michael Floyd, WR Notre Dame

Robert Griffin III, meet the second-best receiver in the 2012 NFL Draft. Notre Dame's Michael Floyd was unbelievable for the Fighting Irish this season, and the kind of big-bodied wideout who could immediately become a match-up problem for any secondary in his way. Floyd doesn't have top-flight speed, but his hands are outstanding and he's a tough tackle in the open field.

23) Detroit Lions - Vontaze Burflict, ILB Arizona State

Arizona State's Vontaze Burflict is a mega-athletic and physical (i.e., flat-out violent) inside linebacker with supposed character concerns, which means he's basically tailor-made for the Lions. Burflict will restore order to Detroit's linebacker corps by bringing the fearsome "take no prisoners" defensive approach that Lions head coach Jim Schwartz craves.

24) Pittsburgh Steelers - Dont'a Hightower, ILB Alabama

Dont'a Hightower was simply dominant in Alabama's rematch with LSU last week, and since the Steel Curtain's linebackers corps could use an upgrade, Hightower--a rangy, powerful defender and leader for the Crimson Tide--could be on Pittsburgh's radar when they're on the clock on draft night. Hightower's also a ruthless prospect who would undoubtedly mesh well with guys like James Harrison and LaMarr Woodley.

25) Denver Broncos - Jerel Worthy, DT Michigan State

It was evident this season that the Broncos's outside pass rush has the personnel to pile up sacks galore, but Denver still needs major upgrades along the interior to eat the run and push the pocket. Michigan State's Jerel Worthy would be an ideal fit in the Broncos' stifling 4-3 scheme, and though he's athletic enough to get into the backfield and do damage, where Worthy truly shines is his ability to dominate the point of attack.

26) Houston Texans - Kendall Wright, WR Baylor

In a cruel twist of irony, the Texans' defense was unbelievably impressive this season, while the offense was injury-riddled and devoid of any real pop through the air. Matt Schaub will be back, but Houston needs to add an explosive receiver who can take some pressure off of Andre Johnson. Baylor's Kendall Wright is pretty much the epitome of "explosive," pairing good hands with a strong frame and jaw-dropping speed, and he'll likely run amok in a division that isn't necessarily known for strong cornerback play.

27) New England Patriots (via New Orleans) - Devon Still, DT Penn State

One could make the case that the Patriots really have no choice but to use one of their two first-round picks on a stud interior defensive lineman. And regardless of which defensive scheme New England employs, the Pats could really use a player like Penn State defensive tackle Devon Still--a powerful, mega-stout defender who could come in and immediately reinforce the defensive line. Still can get to the quarterback, but he's an absolute killer against the run.

28) Green Bay Packers - Melvin Ingram, DE/OLB South Carolina

For a defense inhabited by so many stud players, the Packers' pass rush looked horrific against the Giants last Sunday. Clay Matthews is a consistent terror as an edge rusher, but Green Bay could really use another pass rusher to balance out their attacking defensive scheme. South Carolina's Melvin Ingram could be the answer for the Pack, and is a fast, ruthless defender who will likely jump into the outside linebacker position without missing a beat. Ingram lacks polish and overall technique, but his freakish strength will help him dominate at the point of attack, and he has already demonstrated an ability to effectively eat the run.

29) New England Patriots - Cordy Glenn, OT/G Georgia

It wouldn't be a true NFL draft without the Patriots trading away one of their first-round picks. However, should New England actually keep this pick, Georgia's Cordy Glenn--an absolute house of an offensive linemen--would be a no-brainer addition to an offensive line that is almost close to rebuilt at this point (Nate Solder and Sebastian Vollmer are both very promising tackles, and Logan Mankins is still the best guard in the game). Glenn can play tackle or guard, and he moves absurdly well for a linemen measuring in at 6'5", 350.

30) San Francisco 49ers - Dwayne Allen, TE Clemson

Yes, this is San Francisco taking a page out of the Patriots' playbook and adding an elite tight end to an offense that currently relies on its Pro Bowl tight end (Vernon Davis) for any and all big plays in the passing game. Dwayne Allen has become a do-everything tight end during his time at Clemson, and he'll wow you with his speed, ball skills and willingness to block. Allen is like a Swiss Army Knife at the tight end position.

Come to think of it, the thought of these Vernon Davis and Dwayne Allen playing together is actually kind of nauseating.

31) Baltimore Ravens - Alshon Jeffery, WR South Carolina

Anquan Boldin is getting up there in years, so the Ravens might want to think about getting Joe Flacco a young wideout with great hands and ball skills. South Carolina's Alshon Jeffery is a burly, big-time wideout who can pound lumps on just about any defensive back in his way, and he'll likely be a red zone threat for the Ravens right off the bat. Jeffery would be pretty much a steal at this spot.

32) New York Giants - Zach Brown, OLB North Carolina

Having the last first-round selection means the Giants will have to "settle" for North Carolina's Zach Brown--a linebacker with cornerback-like speed. Brown would be an immediate upgrade at the will linebacker spot in New York's 4-3 scheme, and he's answered questions about instincts with a very impressive senior campaign for the Tarheels.

--------------------------------------

We invite you to follow The Phinsider on Twitter, like The Phinsider on Facebook, and add The Phinsider to your Google+ Circles.

1 recs  |  73 comments

Comments

see my reaction to this pick....

What I will do when I the first round is over and I realize we are doomed to repeat the same season we have been repeating for the last 13 years without a franchise QB…

I had a dream last night that Mr. Ross had an interview(because Mr. Ireland is still hiding in the shadows) and announced that we had traded with the St. Louis Rams and now held the #2 pick in the draft. I know we have to at least go through the Senior Bowl and Combine before any of that would happen. I knew when I woke up it was all just a dream and there was no way we did that before we even had a coach. But I was so happy I could hardly sleep. We need a QB. I can’t see us spending another pick on a RT. If we spend a pick like that on anything it should either be a OLB, or NT(our biggest need on defense). If you can find a special NT in the draft they are worth every bit of that pick and I don’t even need to argue that #8 or #9 is not too high for an OLB.

Yeah i think we need to fill the LBer spot & clean sweep the NY team's next year Thx & your a smart guy rec!
lb

i would love to see the fins draft kuechly

I don't know why we would spend such a high pick for a RT when there are pretty good ones available in the 2nd...
NO OL in first round

Agreed. and Miami should try John Jerry at RT anyway, and there are good tackles available in free agency. Miami has bigger needs at CB, OLB, and safety.

Gonna repost this from last mock draft as I was the last guy in that thread

I just think it would be crazy to draft OL. Crazy.

What teams focus to this extent on OL? What successful teams? We have the best LT in the game. A great (gonna be) second year center. Surely we can find pieces to gel around them that don’t cost a first round pick? Good lines are less about the money spent and high picks used, they’re about stability, staying injury free and good coaching.

A good QB makes his line look good by getting rid of the ball early and moving around the pocket. If we have that our line will be fine. We had an unusual amount of injuries here this year and I think it’s causing people to think our line is a lot worse than it is. Reggie Bush – he of 600 yards a season behind possibly the best line in the NFL – managed to go over 1,000 here. When healthy we were capable of pass blocking too – no matter how ropey things were by the end.

The Giant’s line was woeful this year – last in the league at running. Before this run they’re now on, there was lots of pressure on Eli too. But they win because Eli gets the ball out and the receivers get open.

If we want to improve the offense, priorities should be QB, but since that’s not a real possibility, an elite TE has been shown to be absolutely essential. An extra elite WR never hurts, either. If none of this is available, take the best pass rusher.

Passing the ball and rushing the passer. It all comes down to this. Using the 9th pick on a RT – I know you guys know the definition of insanity, right?

We need an entire O-line filled with 1st round picks... we are 2 picks away from that ...

Once it happens we will be in the Super Bowl every year... Who cares about a franchise

QB, when you can have a franchise O-line... protecting... no one...

Beg to Differ (respectfully of course)...

it’s not like we got Tavaris Jackson or Donovan McNabb back there…

Could the Fins go to the Super Bowl and win it with a dominant Offensive Line, a dominant running game, a clean QB standing back there with tons of time to find an open receiver, and a dominant defense?

Matt Moore may be good enough (assuming we don’t go after Matt Flynn) with a dominant offensive line to “Trent Dilfer” us to a Super Bowl win…look what he was able to do when the running game was working and he had time to throw…

agreed, our line is good enough

and of course I know the definition…

I wrote the damn post!

http://www.thephinsider.com/2011/12/27/2664502/the-definition-of-insanity-im-all-in-are-you

Just read that post. And I am ALL IN. Seriously. I am all in.
glad to have you aboard.
A lot of us are.............
And a lot are not............
Thank you!
We have the best LT in the game. A great (gonna be) second year center. Surely we can find pieces to gel around them that don’t cost a first round pick?

That is the best explanation I have heard yet!

Drew brees and tim brady have the best offensive lines in football

Matt stafford was able to be resurgent because jeff backus stopped being a turnstile and leading to matt stafford being murdered.
Drew brees has like 3 pro bowlers on his line.

Really?
jeff backus stopped being a turnstile

he had more QB pressures than Columbo (36-35) with only 2 fewer sacks allowed. Add in that Gosder Cherilus tied Columbo for sacks allowed and had 26 QB pressures allowed of his own I think Stafford had a good year despite his tackles not because of them. Mind you his guards were near the top of the NFL.

Where were Brees great OL players drafted?
LT Jermon Bushrod – 4th round
LG Carl Nicks – 5th round
C Brian De La Puente – undrafted
RG Jahri Evans – 4th round
RT Zach Strief – 7th round

But for us to have a solid OL we need 5 1st round picks by the sounds of some.

Well Done! Rec'd

Some don’t realize how the QB play affects the play of the OL.

Why thank you......
Who is Tim Brady
Tom's long lost, less talented half-brother
Won't it be nice when .........

We are talking about our next game in January, not the next mock draft (ohhhh someday)
Oh ya, very nice mock draft. I always am leary of trading up or going out of our way to get a particular position, or person because it’s a high profile need. Go for the best player that is availible. This year, it happens to be our biggest need. (Yes RT) I heard that turnstile manufactors are coming out with a new model, the Colombo. It’s really easy to get past, and then out of nowhere, it holds you. Sorry bad humor Trading up for QB is a huge risk that could hurt your team for a long time if it dosen’t work out, See the New York Jest for an example.

John Jerry did well enough at LT this year ...

If we move him to RT, we have that solved. We do not need to waste another pick on an O-lineman to protect no one. We are paying our offensive lineman more to protect Matt Moore than we are paying Matt Moore… I think this is a problem personally… We don’t need to add on to that.. We need someone worthy of him protecting. Otherwise I would rather Matt Moore protect Jake Long.. he is a bigger asset to this team…

A bad personality, yes save our pick for a Jayson Taylor type good call!

REC!

I like most of the picks in this mock draft...

But I disagree with the Dolphins’ pick.

John Jerry has shown a lot of promise at right guard and some promise at right tackle.
Vernon Carey was forced to take a paycut because he went from being a top 8 RT to a top 16 RT, and he was forced to move inside because of Tony Sparano’s unreasonable faith in Marc “I Allow 1+ Sacks Per Game” Colombo. I think Jerry-Carey or Carey-Jerry at RG-RT is an “adequate” right side of the line.

With that in mind, I’m comfortable with two scenarios.

We don’t trade down, and take Courtney Upshaw, who will compete with Misi and hopefully take advantage of all the double teams Cameron Wake draws. If a well-past his prime Taylor can get 7 sacks last year opposite Wake, I’m excited to think what a young pass-rushing threat can do. As the Giants demonstrated against GB last week, a great pass rush makes up for a subpar secondary. Then in the second round, we take Tannehill.
OR
We trade down late in the first round, and with a late first and 2 second round picks, draft the best QB, OLB, and RT/RG available.

In either scenario, we use rounds 3-7 for depth at CB, S, and OL.

RG III and Luck are great prospects...

However, getting either QB will cost us this year’s (and next year’s) early round picks, and I don’t trust either RG III or Luck to be able to outduel Brady or beat a Rex Ryan defense his first couple of years.

However, if we spend those early round picks bolstering our defense and offensive lines, we set up Matt Moore to succeed with Tannehill and Pat Devlin waiting in the wings.

If Matt Moore doesn’t work out this year, then I’d be willing to mortgage our future for Matt Barkley.

However, I think we’re more than just a QB away from being more than a wildcard team, just as last year Atlanta was more than just 1 wide receiver away from being more than a 1 and done playoff team.

Lastly....

I’m really nervous about losing Mike Nolan.

Players would talk about how Nolan did an excellent job preparing them. Even in games where the Dolphins lost, defensive players would say that their game plan was solid and they weren’t surprised by the opposing offense – they just didn’t execute Nolan’s plans effectively.

Even with probably 11 out of 11 starters returning next year, I’m hoping we get another defensive coordinator who can design a defensive game plan that limits NE’s scoring.

I think no one around here has any idea the amount of damage that losing Nolan will cause us

It has been a disastrous season and off-season, all told.

1st half of the season – Start 0-7, sky is falling
2nd half of season – Win just enough meaningless games to move out of range of elite players
Off season – QBs not declaring for draft, coaches rejecting us, losing Nolan

We are in a HELL of a rut right now.


GIFSoup

the FIST PUMP animated GIF is the new REC
Our new coach will be doing this everytime our new OLB Kills the QB!
Carpenter

must have made a Field Goal.

I can't believe I just read 'Pat Devlin waiting in the wings'

Notsureifserious.jpg

lolol

i read that too and immediately facepalmed lol

I actually really like Tannehill.

Then we get Mike Adams as RT in 2nd. Kevin Zeitler in 3rd. Then sign Carlson in free agency and Ladarius Greene in 4th. That wud be on heck of an 0-line with potential at QB. Great potential! And an o-line set for years!

Please, no talk of Tannehill

i can’t believe people are talking about this guy to go in the first round. He is YEARS away from being an NFL QB if he can ever make that jump at all. There was a reason the Aggies moved him to WR and there was a reason the Aggies went 6-6 this past year after starting out in the top 10 at the beginning of the year. Against good competition he was horrible, throwing 10 int’s against Texas, Arkansas, OK State, and Oklahoma. He has padded his stats against outclassed defenses on terrible teams and has a worse record than Henne when it comes to playing in the 4th quarter. Ugghh. There are 7-8 other QB’s I would take ahead of Tannehill in an instant this year.

Not with the 9th pick but if we trade down.

You forget that, unlike Henne, Tannehill has the football smarts. He has the arm. He has the height. He has the mobility. The kid has everything. He is a very intriguing prospect. Yes, me may not start this year, but I’m cool with that if we get him later on in the first.

Is this why the fins are looking at McCoy? Look at the work he did with Tebow. Man, Tebow was meant to be a bust. No way he could be an NFL QB!! Now look. This is one of the reasons the Dolphins maybe taking a look at McCoy.

Henne has the arm and the football smarts and he has the mobility

It’s just that the team doesn’t want to play for him (dropping balls the defense being bad)
But that however is the most important thing in football.

Chad Henne is not a true leader and doesn't have the football smarts. And he's hardly mobile either, not in the griffin, Vick, Tannehill, Rodgers mold anyway.
I mean, how many bad decisions did the guy make!?!?
This is the most intelligent option I've yet seen.

Agree completely. Get a good passer rusher and then develop a passer from a lower round if you can’t get a top one in the first.

I’d even be willing to wait for a low round and pick a project QB, and go with Matt Moore. There’s no reason to waste another pick in the 2nd round on a mediocre prospect. We’d be better off in that situation waiting until next year and doing everything to get Barkley.

Love the first scenario

I wouldn’t mind trading down and getting Dont’a Hightower either. Both those Bama LB’s will be FIERCE in the NFL. I think we’re in the drafting position where we really don’t want to be in. Do we reach for an exciting pick/hope RGIII slips, do we take the “safe” pick with an OL, or do we trade down and stocpile some value?

Personally, I’m on the trade down bandwagon. I would be estatic if we drafted Mark Baron, S from Alabama. We need someone to step in a safety now and someone to eventually dethrone Bell. Bell is still a workhorse, but how long will he be able to still put up this production? Baron is my pick, Not only him, but it’d be awesome to have Hightower slip down as well.

I’m not comfortable drafting a QB in the second round, when Matt Moore just had a fantastic season (in terms of recent Dolphins QB’s). If he backs it up again this year and has another good year, then what? We still have Henne who did show improvement until going down. I know he’s unpopular with fans, but I still think if we surround the team around him, him or Moore will be fine. Look at Sanchize….he’s far worse than Henne, but since his team around him is better, everyone looks at him as a Franchise QB….

hightower's more of a ILB

we need a DE/OLB primary pass rusher especially with JT gone.

This is a huge need for this team

I like Merilius (??) at DE/OLD if we trade down.

And yes, how can we get Flynn when Matt Moore has done so well. What if Matt Moore beats out Flynn just like he did with Chad Henne? Then we’ll have a crap QB with a huge contract on our necks. What’s to say, when Flynn gets that big contract he will take it easy?

Moore didn't beat out Henne

Henne was placed on IR.

But chad Henne didn't start another game did he? And he probably won't be resigned. So I think it's fair to say he I'd beat out chad Henne .
He was on IR

He couldn’t play another game. He won’t be resigned because we will acquire another QB that Moore will backup next year.

But surely if Moore didn't beat out Henne...

Henne would be staying to compete with the new QB and Moore will be gone? But no, against all the odds Moore is staying and Henne is gone. Moore played better than Henne ever has done.

Moore is signed for another year where Henne is a UFA

Henne was likely done in Miami the moment he was placed on IR no matter how Moore did.

8-8 here we come

No need to disagree anymore or your just a troll

I like Moore as our QB

but if bring another in, I’d prefer signing Flynn or drafting Tannehill. I’d love to get a Pro Bowl caliber RT, but a pass rusher would help our DB’s shorten the coverage zones. We need a TE, and wouldn’t mind 2 if we could get an extra pick in the 3rd, like the idea of Allen and Fleener.
Laurent Robinson might be a good sign at WR.

I like the pick!

I would be surprised if cinci didnt move up to grab Richardson if he falls out of the top 10.

Im ok with it

If we do everything in our power to trade up and it just doesn’t happen, then I don’t mind this pick.
There’s only 2 top tier qbs available so it’s the smart thing to do.

I can't wait to see these after FA acqusitions...

rec’d

Do you think the issues with Dre Kirkpatrick

Will drop him in the draft at all? I would be surprised to see Richardson drop out of the top 10.

I got us Tradeing back to the Cinncinatti Bengals, Us taking there 2-3 in this draft & next-years #1 off there hands!
And to the Chiefs???

They have arguably the best back in football coming back next year…

But that would be insane

I agree with Beaver

Try to trade down & get high picks for next year and go in to next years draft loaded.

Beav is usually loaded...

lol

If we aren’t getting a QB in the first round we should get a playmaker. We need a pass rusher…

This ^^^
Should the Dolphins stay in the 3-4, they'll have the option of Upshaw or Mercilus at OLB

Either guy would be ridiculous in Miami.

Also, remember that I explore a different draft scenario for the Dolphins each week. Thus far, I’ve given Miami a quarterback, outside linebacker, receiver and offensive tackle. Of those picks, I thought the linebacker (Courtney Upshaw) made the most sense. He’s just good at everything—rushing the passer, taking on the run, dropping into coverage, etc. However, I’ll continue to explore options as we near closer to the draft. My goal is to exhaust all of our options and settle on the best prospect available at No.8/9. Right now, I can’t imagine any defensive front-seven prospects who will have more momentum than Upshaw or Mercilus by the time April rolls around.

Mercilus is Aldon Smith 2.0; Upshaw is a prototype outside linebacker in the 3-4. I’ll gladly take one of them.

I get what you are trying to do KMB ... excellent posts by the way.

To me this draft is really simple. If Miami can’t get the QB, then pass rusher is the only other option. QB is the biggest need on offense. Pass rusher is the biggest need on defense. It is really that simple to me.

I don’t know Upshaw. I did get to watch a lot of Mercilus here in Big Ten country. I love his ability and he has a great football name. #8 or #9 might be a little high for him, but I would risk “reaching” for Mercilus instead of taking a RT.

We'd be doing a great disservice to our 3-4 scheme if we didn't address the OLB position early in this draft

Koa Misi is a big “so what?” at that position, and it’d be stellar if we could actually pile up sacks with a player not named Cameron Wake.

I think not spending more picks at the LB position has been one of the biggest mistakes in the draft for this organization since Parcells and Co. came to town.

If you are committed to running a 3-4 defense, you need LB’s. A 3-4, by its design, is a LB heavy defense. In the last 4 drafts, Misi is the only LB taken in the top 3 round in any of those drafts. To make up for that, the Phins had to overpay for Dansby and Burnett, sign Wake from Canada (great move) and bring back an aging JT.

Agreed, we need to address the LB position

Especially if we stay in the 3-4 (my preference) and a LaMarr Woodley clone would be ideal.

TRADE DOWN !

The dolphins should trade down and try to get a tackle and dwayne allen. We are all talking about trading up but what about trading down and getting a bunch of really good players. Maybe get a good pass rushing linebacker, right tackle, dwayne allen or even a receiver? Trading down would bring in a bunch of good players and that would be the “smart move.” What if matt moore is the real deal? Get this team more talent and find out this year is what i say…. If he isn’t then we go after Barkley next year who will come in with a talented team just like were giving to Moore this year by trading down!

Does everyone realize that mock drafts are based on what you "think" will happen and not what you "want" to happen?

It seems to me that many of you are arguing the latter.

It's called emotions running amuck....

we definately would have to give up a small ransom for RGIII

Well if its a small one then I am in.

You must Login with your SB Nation account and be a member of The Phinsider to post a comment.